Senator pushes to hold Fauci in contempt after he declined to answer COVID-related questions in hearing

News brief
Topics
Anti-science
COVID-19
Anthony Fauci, MD
Christopher Michel / Wikimedia Commons

After Anthony Fauci, MD, declined to answer questions during a hearing of a congressional committee chaired by Sen. Rand Paul (R-KY) yesterday, Paul says he is moving to hold the former National Institutes of Allergy and Infectious Diseases director in contempt of Congress, he told reporters.

Throughout the contentious hearing of the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee, Fauci invoked the Fifth Amendment in response to questions and accusations that he attempted to obscure the true origins of the COVID-19 pandemic. 

The senator said the vote will occur in committee next week. Some Republican committee members allege that Fauci had no right to take the Fifth, because the preemptive pardon he received from former President Joe Biden conferred immunity from criminal prosecution.

“We believe that with his… immunity from criminal liability, that he didn’t need to hide behind the Fifth Amendment and that maybe the Fifth Amendment doesn’t attach when you have a pardon in place,” Paul said. “That’ll be a legal question… and then there’s a question of whether or not the Department of Justice will take that up.”

During the hearing, Fauci said he believes in congressional oversight but took issue with Paul’s “obvious obsession with calling for my prosecution.”

A dogged, years-long pursuit

Paul has long pursued Fauci, who led the COVID-19 response during the first Trump administration and the Biden administration, and called for his criminal prosecution.

We believe that with his… immunity from criminal liability, that he didn’t need to hide behind the Fifth Amendment and that maybe the Fifth Amendment doesn’t attach when you have a pardon in place.

Sen. Rand Paul

The senator alleges that Fauci supported gain-of-function research in Wuhan, China, that resulted in the creation and accidental release of SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID, and that he tried to suppress evidence of a lab leak, which Fauci disputes. 

No conclusive evidence of a lab leak has been uncovered, though the Trump administration now says evidence points to the creation of the virus in a National Institutes of Health–funded lab. Fauci has said that a lab leak cannot be ruled out.

Nominees to lead CDC, pandemic preparedness office move forward in Senate committee vote

News brief
Topics
Public Health

The Senate health committee today approved President Donald Trump’s nominees to lead the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and the Administration for Strategic Preparedness and Response (ASPR).

The approval of Erica Schwartz, MD, MPH, JD, to lead the CDC by all Republican members and one Democrat on the Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor & Pensions means her nomination now heads to the full Senate floor. 

Senate committee room with empty chairs
wellesenterprises / iStock

The approval comes despite a rocky confirmation hearing, in which several senators on the committee appeared dismayed by some of Schwartz’s responses to their questions. But support from committee chair Bill Cassidy (R-LA), a key vote, assured that Schwartz would move forward.

Cassidy receives assurances, again

The nomination of Sean Kaufman, MPH, to lead ASPR also moved forward, with the nominee opposed by all Democrats on the committee. Cassidy, who assailed Kaufman for his previous criticism of vaccines during his July 15 confirmation hearing, said Kaufman had “owned up” to anti-vaccine statements. 

Cassidy added that his support was contingent upon assurances he received from Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) officials.

“I am assured, if he is confirmed, [that] he will not be involved in vaccine policy, nor will he be the ultimate decision-maker on certain issues, like mRNA, because of his past statements,” Cassidy said before his vote. 

Cassidy, who was defeated in a primary in May and will leave the Senate next year, has been widely criticized for his crucial vote to confirm HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., despite reservations about his views on vaccines. Prior to that vote, Cassidy received assurances from the Trump administration that Kennedy would not undermine US vaccine policy.

Schwartz and Kaufman are both likely to be confirmed by the full Senate.

This week's top reads

  1. No link between MMR vaccination before age 2 and autism, large US study suggests

    The findings reinforce existing evidence of the safety of MMR vaccination, the authors say.

    Meghan Holohan

  2. Cyclospora infections increasing in 2 US outbreaks

    Cyclosporiasis cases in a second outbreak not connected to lettuce continue to climb nationwide.

    Meghan Holohan
    Man with upset stomach

  3. Over 400 state vaccine bills, 9 new laws, 2 fed charters, and 1 step closer to a CDC director: The State of US Vaccine Policy

    Only 9 of the 400 bills became law, and no state eliminated childhood immunization requirements.

    Izzy Brandstetter Figueroa, MPH, Riley Mulholland, MPH, Jess Steier, DrPH
    Sprinters on track

  4. Fauci invokes Fifth Amendment during congressional hearing

    The nation’s former top infectious disease expert refused to answer questions from Sen. Rand Paul and others who accused him of misleading the country about the origins of COVID.

    Chris Dall
    Anthony Fauci speaking at an NIH event

  5. After lab study finds interspecies spread of CWD prions, experts debate significance for humans

    The findings don’t confirm that the fatal disease is a threat to people but do offer important clues to what infection might look like in humans.

    Mary Van Beusekom
    Two macaques with baby

  6. Senator pushes to hold Fauci in contempt after he declined to answer COVID-related questions in hearing

    Some Republican committee members allege that Fauci had no right to invoke the Fifth Amendment, because a pardon protects him from criminal prosecution.

    Mary Van Beusekom

  7. Feds shut down ‘dangerous’ gain-of-function research, tighten oversight of foreign collaboration

    But some experts say it will impede the US’s ability to address infectious disease threats and respond to outbreaks.

    Mary Van Beusekom
    Biosafety lab worker

  8. COVID is still here. Is the pandemic?

    CIDRAP Director Michael Osterholm explains what makes a pandemic, if we’re still in one, and what gives a pathogen pandemic potential. 

    Laine Bergeson
    Michael Osterholm speaking on a panel

  9. Large US Cyclospora outbreak expands to 6 more states

    Although cases continue to mount, experts say it doesn’t necessarily mean that the outbreak is ongoing.

    Meghan Holohan
    Lettuce in a field

  10. Can air purifiers prevent flu and COVID-19 in nursing homes? Only if they’re used properly

    A randomized controlled trial found that air purifiers didn’t prevent respiratory infections in nursing homes. But experts say that’s because the machines were too small and not used consistently.

    Liz Szabo
    A woman with short gray hair sits on a chair with a book in her lap and points to a large air purifier next to her.

Our underwriters

Unrestricted financial support provided by

Unorthodox Philanthropy logo
Leading Underwriter
Albert Victor Ravenholt Fund
Supporting Underwriter
Become an Underwriter