A meta-analysis of 11 studies concludes that self-testing for human papilloma virus (HPV) using urine or vaginal samples accurately detects pre-cancerous cells caused by HPV, also known as high-grade squamous intraepithelial lesions (HSIL+).
This paper, published in the Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology Research, reinforces the precision of self-collection testing for HPV, which could increase access to screening.
“The outcomes of this investigation indicate that HPV testing performed using both self-collected urine specimen and vaginal specimens achieved a high sensitivity in detecting HSIL+,” wrote the Taiwanese authors.
High sensitivity for self-collected vaginal swabs
The World Health Organization (WHO) hopes to eliminate cervical cancer by 2030 and sees HPV self-collecting kits as one way to expand screening to reach more women, especially those who have not yet undergone HPV testing.
The researchers hoped to understand the accuracy of self-testing methods by looking at studies that examined the precision of self-collected HPV kits in finding abnormal cells using urine or vaginal samples. The papers included in the analysis were based on 3,534 self-collected urine samples and 3,523 vaginal samples.
The distribution of self-sampling kits has the potential to yield a low rate of adverse events and a high level of satisfaction among patients.
Self-collection of urine samples had a pooled sensitivity of 81%, while self-testing with vaginal swabs had a pooled sensitivity of 88.6% for detecting pre-cancerous cells.
“The meta-analysis corroborated the high sensitivity of HPV testing with self-collected vaginal specimens,” the authors wrote. “The distribution of self-sampling kits has the potential to yield a low rate of adverse events and a high level of satisfaction among patients.”