
A study conducted at Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) outpatient clinics found that antibiotic prescribing for asymptomatic bacteriuria (ASB) is prevalent, researchers reported yesterday in the American Journal of Infection Control.
For the retrospective cohort study, researchers from VA hospitals in Pennsylvania, Ohio, and Illinois reviewed medical charts from outpatient visits at any VA medical center from January 2019 through December 2022 that were associated with a positive urine culture collected within 3 days before or after the visit. They categorized the visits into three groups based on urinary tract infection (UTI)–specific symptoms (UTI-present, UTI-unlikely, and UTI-absent) and looked at which visits received antibiotics and why.
The objective of the study was to assess the current state of inappropriate antibiotic prescribing for ASB—the presence of bacteria in urine with no specific symptoms of UTI—at VA outpatient clinics. Although the Infectious Diseases Society of America and other groups advocate against routine ASB screening and treatment because of clinical ineffectiveness and concerns about increased risk of antimicrobial resistance, studies suggest that inappropriate antibiotic prescribing for ASB persists in many US outpatient settings.
Prescribing driven by urine test results
Of the 484 medical charts reviewed, 258 (53%) were categorized as UTI-present, and 113 (23%) each as UTI-unlikely and UTI-absent. Most (90%) of the UTI-present visits resulted in antibiotic prescriptions, and 66% of the UTI-absent and 58% of UTI-unlikely visits also received antibiotic prescriptions.
In 37.6% of the UTI-absent and 26.7% of the UTI-unlikely visits that resulted in antibiotic prescriptions, the provider appeared to be prescribing in response to urinalysis or urine culture results. For 18.4% of these prescriptions, the provider cited an inappropriate symptom as indicative of UTI.
Chart review also revealed several occasions in which urine tests were ordered by providers with no discernable clinical reason for collecting a urine sample.
The study authors say the findings indicate that a significant proportion of veterans experienced unnecessary antibiotic exposure and show that continued use of urine testing appears to be driving unnecessary treatment.
"Improving diagnostic stewardship in the ordering of urinalysis and urine cultures could represent a critical first step in reducing inappropriate ASB prescribing," they wrote.