A new review published in JAMA Network Open describes how often ethics are incorporated in infectious diseases international clinical practice guidelines (CPGL) and finds planning and actual consideration of ethical issues in infectious disease CPGL are limited.
To perform the analysis, the authors conducted a systematic search for CPGL specific to infectious diseases published between January 2021 and December 2023 in three guideline databases, most from high-income countries.
The authors of the study reviewed 115 CPGL and found only 32 (27.8%) dedicated a section or paragraph to ethical considerations. Only a single CPGL mentioned issues of gender balance policies in authorship.
Affordability most often addressed
Costs of diagnostics and treatment affordability were mentioned in 53 guidelines analyzed, while 41 guidelines mention cost or benefit centered on the patient. Access to care was addressed in 50 of the guidelines, but allocation of resources was addressed in only 35 of the guidelinesanalyzed.
The most common ethical issues addressed were related to justice (including affordability and access to care).
“Less than a third of CPGL dedicated a section or paragraph to ethical considerations, and only half of guidelines addressed minority populations,” the authors wrote. “The most common ethical issues addressed were related to justice (including affordability and access to care).”
The authors said more planning for and attention to ethical considerations is crucial.
“Complex ethical issues apply to the field of infectious diseases because of disproportionate disease burdens in vulnerable populations and the public health risks related to the spread of infection,” they wrote.